Author: Susan L. Tuttle

Book Review: The Novel Adventures of Natalie Daughtry by Susan L. Tuttle

Published on 02/19/2025 by Carla Bruns

Book cover design for “The Novel Adventures of Natalie Daughtry” by Susan L. Tuttle, part of the “Treasures of Halstead Manor” series, featuring a vintage green nautical map background with latitude and longitude lines, a silhouetted female figure casting a shadow, bold white serif typography, and a minimalist gold open book icon, conveying historical fiction, mystery, and adventure themes.
The Novel Adventures of Natalie Daughtry by Susan L. Tuttle
Series: Treasures of Halstead Manor – Book 2
Publisher: Kregel Publications
Release Date: March 18, 2025
Genre: Adventure, Contemporary Romance
Pages: 361
Links: Book Page
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.

In pursuit of a rare book, will Natalie and Mason find each other again?

With her twenty-plus-year marriage on the brink of collapse, bookish Natalie Daughtry immerses herself in her new bookstore job. When the mysterious Caspar gathers Natalie and her friends Everleigh and Brooke for the second time, she’s ready for an adventure to disperse the turmoil clouding her marriage. Caspar enlists their help in searching for a rumored copy of Lewis Carroll’s handwritten and illustrated manuscript of Alice’s Adventures Under Ground. Natalie is immediately enticed–this is the perfect distraction.

But then Mason joins the team, and suddenly Natalie and her husband are side-by-side on the search for this elusive treasure. Being forced to work together has them tumbling deep into their past, seeking answers to old misunderstandings. When they emerge from the rabbit hole, things aren’t the same. Will they rediscover the love that once held the pages of their life together?

PURCHASE LINKS:
Goodreads | Kregel Publications | Amazon
Barnes & Noble | Christianbook


When I first started reading this book, I had flashbacks to the original Charlie’s Angels series because I’m just that old. Okay, some of them I watched as reruns because it’s not really a show for six-year-olds. But I digress. Those vibes lessened as I got further into the book and became enthralled with everything that was happening. Between Natalie and Mason’s marriage issues, running all over the globe, and trying to find this manuscript, there was just so much to take in. 

I am all for the adventure in this book, but one thing I kept thinking about over and over was how thankful I am for my husband. The things Natalie and Mason face are very real communication issues that I’m sure happen in many marriage. I felt Natalie was unusually hard on Mason, and while she sometimes said the right things to him, I didn’t feel that her actions or thoughts always matched the words coming out of her mouth. Not that I’ve ever done that (ahem… now I’m just flat-out telling fibs). Mason I adored—clearly more than Natalie in the beginning. He had his issues, but it seemed like he was trying just a smidge harder than Natalie. Come on, Nat! 

Oh, I shouldn’t forget to tell you… there were very clearly marked time hops in this book. It was fascinating to hear the thoughts of Luciana Perez, the daughter of the original owner of the book—how the book came to be, the impact it had on Luciana, and hints on its possible whereabouts.  

After reading this book, I’m hooked. I want to read the first book in the series and can’t wait for book three. For lovers of books about books, history, and stories that take you around the world, this shouldn’t be missed. 


The Rare Jewel of Everleigh Wheaton


Susan L. Tuttle

Susan L. Tuttle is a pastor’s wife, mom, and the director of women’s ministry at her church near Grand Rapids, Michigan. Her previous work includes the Along Came Love series, and the Carol Award finalist Love You, Truly.

Connect with Susan by visiting susanltuttle.com to follow her on social media or subscribe to email newsletter updates.

Hi!

Welcome to Carla’s Book Crush, a thoughtful space for readers who love books, reflection, faith, and the literary life. Here you’ll find honest book reviews, reading reflections, deep dives into reading habits, conversations about faith and thoughtful living, and the occasional look into the hobbies and interests that shape a well read life. From Amish romance and contemporary fiction to nonfiction, Bible study resources, and literary curiosity, this is a place for readers seeking depth, encouragement, and stories that linger long after the final page.

Goodreads

Pinterest

Why I don’t do star ratings... All authors, all books, have someone who labored over them and someone who loves reading them. A star rating is an arbetrary system that is only relevant to the person who provided the rating. I’m always honest with my opnions and feelngs about a book and how it resonated with me. You can hear that in the words that I pen. I explain more about this decision in the article For the Love of Books.


Stay in the story.