Amish Romance Reviews: Clean Romance Roundup

I’ve had a lot of time recently to reflect on how I would like to do my book reviews. While I read primarily romance, I’ve decided to group them into a few subcategories. And, obviously, because it’s me, I’m starting with Amish romances. This month I’ve read three. This may not seem like a lot of books given how much I love Amish romance, but I read on average six books a month. So, yes, about half of all my reading is dedicated to my favorite genre. And, to see if I can get you to jump on this Amish train (ahem, buggy), I have a great recommendation for you. So here is my first monthly clean romance book review roundup.


A Home for His Amish Children | Shooting Sunshine | The Rise and Fall of Miss Fannie’s Biscuits
Wanda E. Brunstetter | Martha Bolton | Wendy Rich Stetson | Virginia Wise

Shooting Sunshine by Wendy Rich Stetson
Publisher: Wild Rose Press
Publication Date: September 30, 2024
Pages: 374
Format: ebook – Author
Add to Goodreads
Buy on Amazon

On assignment in Green Ridge, PA, New York photojournalist Darcy King will stop at nothing to bag a prestigious staff position at Hudson Magazine. Just one problem: her subjects are Amish, and they shun having their pictures taken.

As a wild teen on his Amish Rumspringa, Samuel Rishel fell prey to a photographer who splashed his face on a romance novel and left him with trust issues. Older and definitely wiser, he wants nothing to do with cameras until a pretty young photographer arrives in the family’s farmhouse B&B. Eager to support his mother’s fledgling business, he’ll help Darcy on one condition—no pictures of faces allowed.

Will Samuel and Darcy go from enemies to something more? Or will a single photograph shatter their trust forever?

Five stars. Really? Is that all I can give? Sigh, I’ll go with five. The writing style of this book is so unexpected for an Amish romance. And I mean that in a very good way. I never wanted to put this book down and I’ll reread it. I fell in love with all the characters. Especially Darcy, Samual, and sassy Pammy who owns the local bakery. If I say more, I’ll just spoil the whole thing for you.    

I often get asked by people who do not read Amish books, what Amish book I recommend to them. 𝘛𝘩𝘪𝘴. This is the book. If you love Amish romance, then 100% without a doubt you need to read this. But if you aren’t sure if the genre is for you, or maybe you haven’t liked it in the past, this book will take you in and make you fall in love with all things Amish.   

Rating: 5 out of 5.

A Home for His Amish Children by Virginia Wise
Series: Bluebird Hills – Book 4
Publisher: Love Inspired
Publication Date: January 21, 2025
Pages: 272
Format: ebook – Author
Add to Goodreads
Buy on Amazon

The wife he didn’t expect

Could be exactly what he needs

With his house and business destroyed in a fire, widower Silas Hochstetler desperately needs somewhere for him and his children to live. Needing help to pay her mortgage—and secretly longing for a family of her own—spinster Mary King answers his ad for a wife. Navigating their new life together with the children isn’t as easy as they thought, though neither can ignore the spark between them. They might be strangers, but their marriage of convenience might just lead to something real…

I was hooked the moment I opened the book. Here we have this timid woman, Mousy Mary as her mean brother calls her, waiting for a man she has never met before to become her husband. How bold! Silas is sweet and strong and tries so hard to guard his heart. He wants to make this more of a business arrangement with Mary but she’s not the kind you ignore. It was heartwarming to see Mary blossom throughout the book and become her own. With the help of her friends and Sila’s quiet comforting ways, she becomes the person she was always meant to be. And it’s not timid at all, as her step-daughter finds out. When Mary starts standing up to Becky, you can see the change in both characters from that point on.  

Wise always writes wonderful books and this one does not disappoint. I adore the way this was written. It’s the right mix of Amish, romance, and real-life rolled up into one. Anyone who delights in Amish romance will want to read this. 

Rating: 5 out of 5.

The Rise and Fall of Miss Fannie’s Biscuits by Wanda E. Brunstetter & Martha Bolton
Publisher: Barbour Fiction
Publication Date: January 1, 2025
Genres: Mystery | Amish Romance
Pages: 256
Format: ebook – NetGalley
Add to Goodreads
Buy on Amazon

Why Are Baking Contestants Disappearing?

Mysteries have a way of following Fannie Miller, so when she makes it into the finals of the Tuscarawas County Baking Contest and contestants start disappearing, she calls on her old friend Foster Bates, a retired cop and part-time private investigator. Could it be that other finalists—like the couple on verge of divorce who need the prize money. . .or the three Beiler sisters, always in a huddle whispering—are somehow responsible for these disappearances, thinning out the competition? One thing is certain—Foster and Fannie will stay on the case until the end, and everyone involved will learn something important about baking contests, mystery solving, and life.

It took a while for me to really get into the book. The writing is too formal and not conversational in tone. At times the fact that there were two writers seemed very apparent because not everything was as cohesive as it should be. About halfway into the book things started to flow a little better and there were parts that got a genuine laugh out of me.

The characters were fun and pithy. Fanny and Foster’s relationship was realistic and endearing. The three sisters who were key secondary characters seemed a little over the top. Especially given that they owned a bakery and their behavior didn’t seem to impact sales.

Overall, I thought this was an okay read. It was not a typical Brunstetter book in my opinion so it fell a little flat for me. At the end of the book, I did read Bolton’s credentials which were very impressive with many plays and musicals under her belt. 𝘛𝘩𝘦 𝘙𝘪𝘴𝘦 𝘢𝘯𝘥 𝘍𝘢𝘭𝘭 𝘰𝘧 𝘔𝘪𝘴𝘴 𝘍𝘢𝘯𝘯𝘪𝘦’𝘴 𝘉𝘪𝘴𝘤𝘶𝘪𝘵𝘴 has been made into a musical and it made the writing style and even ending of the book make much more sense. I think it will be a delightful musical and one I’d enjoy seeing. Had I known that upfront, I would have approached this read from a different perspective and potentially would have enjoyed it more.

Rating: 3 out of 5.

What are you reading?

In some instances, I receive books through the publisher, author, or NetGalley. This is marked next to “Format”. This in no way sways my opinion. All opinions are my own.


Get faith filled favorites straight to your inbox.

  1. Carla Avatar

    I’ve not read anything by Wendy Rich Stetson, but I will see if my library has this one. Too bad Miss Fannie’s Biscuits wasn’t a good one. I find her books are hit or miss for me. Great reviews, Carla.

    Like

    1. Carla Bruns Avatar

      Wendy’s book is really good! I feel like Wanda changed her writing style working with someone else or perhaps she didn’t write that much of it. I’m reading The Peacemaker by her now and it’s so good. I loved the first book in this series and this one is just as good.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Carla Avatar

        Good to hear that when writing by herself, she is still one to watch for.

        Like

  2. Jodie | That Happy Reader Avatar

    I really enjoy a clean romance! Thanks for the recommendations.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Carla Bruns Avatar

      You’re welcome, Jodie!

      Like

  3. buffywnabe Avatar

    The first two sound like real winners for you! Thanks for sharing these. I haven’t read any Amish romances, but your reviews have got me thinking about picking one up!

    https://lisalovesliterature.bookblog.io/2025/01/18/lisa-loves-to-discuss-5-book-clubs-and-read-alongs/

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Carla Bruns Avatar

      They really were. But, of course, I really love my Amish romance.

      Like

  4. Liz Dexter Avatar

    Those first two look great. People never realise that within the romance genre you often find people flourishing and blossoming personally as Mary seems to in the second one – lovely!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Carla Bruns Avatar

      Yes, I really enjoy that many romance books are also about personal growth.

      Liked by 1 person

  5. the bookworm Avatar

    I used to totally be on the Amish train and you’re tempting me to get back on lol. I just added Shooting Sunshine to my Goodreads TBR.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Carla Bruns Avatar

      That one is the best one for jumping back on the train!

      Like

Leave a reply to buffywnabe Cancel reply

Welcome to Carla’s Book Crush where I share my favorite clean, Christian reads. I review everything from Amish and historical romance to suspense, contemporary fiction, nonfiction, and the occasional devotional. If it has heart, hope, and a message that points back to Christ, it’s probably on my shelf. I also love chatting with authors and featuring interviews that give you a peek behind the pages. Whether you’re looking for a new release, a cozy weekend read, or just something uplifting and well-written, you’re in the right place. Clean stories. Encouraging faith. Books worth reading.