Book Review: Christmas at Sugar Plum Manor by Roseanna M. White

Yes, the holidays have come and gone but my reviews have not. I did read this in December but felt it was just too good not to post the review here. Whether you’re looking to expand your TBR for the holidays or just want a sweet historical romance to read right now, this one is for you.

Christmas at Sugar Plum Manor by Roseanna M. White
Publisher: Bethany House Publishers
Publication Date: September 3, 2024
Genres: Christian | Historical Fiction | Romance
Pages: 204
Format: Paperback
Add to Goodreads
Buy on Amazon

The Nutcracker and Edwardian-Era England combine to weave a magical tale of love and friendship at Christmastime.

As the beloved stepdaughter of the Earl of Castleton, Lady Mariah Lyons cherishes her home at Plumford Manor, but her idyllic world will be threatened when the estate passes to Cyril Lightbourne, a childhood friend she hasn’t seen or heard from in years. Once, Mariah dreamed their friendship would kindle into something more, but that was before she heard Cyril was courting the cruelhearted Lady Pearl. Now Mariah is willing to welcome him as a friend and pray he will be the heir her stepfather needs, but she’ll keep her heart locked safely away from anyone with such poor taste.

Cyril Lightbourne has long avoided returning to Plumford Manor, yet he reluctantly arrives in time for Christmas. When his friendship with Lady Mariah reignites, he finds himself caught between his affection for her and her family’s misunderstanding of his attachment to Lady Pearl. Then, more trouble arrives in the form of a Danish lord on a mission to win Mariah’s hand by Christmas. Will the magic of the holiday season help lead to the discovery of true love, or will duty to country leave all longing for what could have been?

Rating: 4 out of 5.

Lady Mariah Lyons is the beloved stepdaughter to the Earl of Castleton. She’s whimsical and fun and full of life. And, she’s lucky. Earl of Castleton does not expect her to marry for gains but allows her to choose her husband for love. Her childhood friend and crush, Cyril Lightbourne, is the distant cousin of the Earl and the heir apparent of the title and the estate and is coming to stay but they have not spoken in years and the boy has not grown to the man she has expected.    

Cyril arrives at the castle out of duty only and starts training under the Earl to be ready to take the reins. At the same time that he arrives, Lord Gyldenkrone, a handsome Danish man who wants Lady Mariah as his bride. While Cyril feels that Mariah has changed over the years, he doesn’t think that this cold, hard-hearted man is right for Mariah.   

It took me a bit to get into this book because I’m not a fan of love triangles. Lady Mariah was spontaneous and caring. At times she appears immature but at other times very down to earth and realistic. Cyril Lightbourne had a better balance for his character.  Mature but yet still inquisitive. However, despite his cold, chilly demeanor, I fell in love with Lord Gyldenkrone. While this book has inspirations from The Nutcraker, I found Gylenkrone like the Grinch. You could slowly see his heart start opening up and thawing. He really made the book for me.   

I think this book is great if you’re looking for a light-hearted historical read. Despite The Nutcracker and Christmas theme, I think it could be enjoyed at any time.   

What are you reading?


Love clean Christian reads?

Get them straight to your inbox.

9 responses to “Book Review: Christmas at Sugar Plum Manor by Roseanna M. White”

  1. buffywnabe Avatar

    Beautiful cover! Glad you enjoyed it, I say read whatever type of book you enjoy at any time of the year!

    https://lisalovesliterature.bookblog.io/2025/01/17/author-interview-giveaway-michelle-sodaro/

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Carla Bruns Avatar

      Thanks, Lisa!

      Like

  2. Carla Avatar

    I read Christmas year round and actually do Christmas in July. This sounds lovely, Carla.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Carla Bruns Avatar

      I love the idea of Christmas is July for reading! I already watch the Christmas movies during that time.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Carla Avatar

        It’s fun to read Christmas books when it is hot out.

        Like

  3. the bookworm Avatar

    This sounds like a nice one and I don’t mind a love triangle. Great review.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Carla Bruns Avatar

      I think more people like he love triangle and don’t, but that’s just based on what I see. It was still a great book despite the fact that that’s not really one of my go to tropes.

      Like

  4. Rebecca Avatar

    I also read this one and it was such a sweet little read! My first by the author, but I’ll now be giving her non-Christmas reads a try :)

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a reply to the bookworm Cancel reply

Welcome to Carla’s Book Crush where I share my favorite clean, Christian reads. I review everything from Amish and historical romance to suspense, contemporary fiction, nonfiction, and the occasional devotional. If it has heart, hope, and a message that points back to Christ, it’s probably on my shelf. I also love chatting with authors and featuring interviews that give you a peek behind the pages. Whether you’re looking for a new release, a cozy weekend read, or just something uplifting and well-written, you’re in the right place. Clean stories. Encouraging faith. Books worth reading.

5 Stars – Overwhelmed me in a good way!
4 Stars – Strongly moved me
3 Stars – Entertaining, worth the read
2 Stars – Meh, take it or leave it
1 Star – Nails on a chalkboard