Faith & Second Chances
Faith Rekindled: Faith that once felt distant is slowly restored through hardship, love, or community.
- An Amish Widow’s Hope by Pamela Desmond Wright
- His Amish Christmas Surprise by Virginia Wise
- Her Amish Refuge by Pamela Desmond Wright
- Her Forbidden Christmas Match by Emma Miller
- Misgivings by Anne Gibson
- Their Surprise Reunion by Shelley Shepard Gray
- Rediscovering Christmas by Mindy Obenhaus
Finding Faith Under Fire: When everything falls apart, turning to God becomes the only option left.
- Canyon of Deceit by DiAnn Mills
- Girl Lost by Kate Angelo
- Shadowed Witness by Angela Carlisle
Guarded or Wounded Heart: Past pain makes love feel risky, and trust does not come easily.
- An Amish Baby in Her Arms by Patricia Johns
- B Is for Bonnet by Shelley Shepard Gray
- Christmas at Spruce Hill Farm by Kathryn Springer
- Christmas at Sugar Plum Manor by Roseanna M. White
- Discovering Dahlia by Jennifer Moore
- Falling for the Amish Rival by Virginia Wise
- A Family on His Doorstep by Alena Auguste
- The Farmer’s Marriage Bargain by Heidi Main
- Finding You by Amy Clipston
- Green Pastures by Patricia Johns
- Heart of Beauty by Danielle Grandinetti
- His Amish Christmas Surprise by Virginia Wise
- His Perfect Bride by Jody Hedlund
- A Home for His Amish Children by Virginia Wise
- The Hunted Heir by Jayna Breigh
- Kate Landry Has a Plan by Rebekah Millet
- Madly Yours by Elle M. Adams
- Misgivings by Anne Gibson
- My Grumpy Boss Valentine by Em Tate
- An Overdue Match by Sarah Monzon
- Rescued at Christmas by Janice Carter
- Small Town Harmony by Milla Holt
- A Stolen Kiss by Mindy Steele
- A Thieving at Carlton House by Erica Vetsch
- With All Her Heart by Kelly Irvin
- Yours Blindly by Rose Fresquez
Scripture as Comfort: God’s Word brings peace, clarity, and reassurance when emotions run high.
- Her Amish Refuge by Pamela Desmond Wright
- Hunted for the Holidays by Deena Alexander
- Misgivings by Anne Gibson
- Rediscovering Christmas by Mindy Obenhaus
Prayer in Crisis: Prayer is the first response when fear, danger, or impossible choices arise.
- Following the Clues by Dana Mentink
- Hunted for the Holidays by Deena Alexander
- Hunting the Amish Witness by Dana R. Lynn
- Kidnapped for Ransom by Jacqueline Adam
- A Scheming in Parliament by Erica Vetsch
- Taken at Christmas by Jodie Bailey
Faith Journey Arc: Spiritual growth unfolds naturally, moving from uncertainty toward deeper trust.
- A is For Amish by Shelley Shepard Gray
- Amish Sleigh Bells by Patricia Johns
- An Amish Baby in Her Arms by Patricia Johns
- B Is for Bonnet by Shelley Shepard Gray
- The Christmas Gatheringby Shelley Shepard Gray; Rachel J. Good; Lenora Worth
- Finding You by Amy Clipston
- Green Pastures by Patricia Johns
- Hunting for a Husband by Mindy Steele
- The Novel Adventures of Natalie Daughtry by Susan L. Tuttle
- Sense and Suitability by Pepper Basham
- Small Town Harmony by Milla Holt
- An Unexpected Companion by Mindy Obenhaus
- A Year of Flowers by Suzanne Woods Fisher
The Prodigal Returns: Someone who walked away comes back seeking grace, healing, and belonging.
- The Amish Baby Scandal by Virginia Wise
- The Christmas Gathering by Shelley Shepard Gray; Rachel J. Good; Lenora Worth
- Green Pastures by Patricia Johns
- Her Amish Refuge by Pamela Desmond Wright
Romance and Relationship Tropes
Second Chance Romance: Love finds its way back after separation, regret, and unfinished business.
- An Amish Barn Raising: Three Stories by Amy Clipston, Kelly Irvin, Kathleen Fuller
- An Amish Widow’s Hope by Pamela Desmond Wright
- Christmas at Spruce Hill Farm by Kathryn Springer
- Finding You by Amy Clipston
- Her Amish Country Husband by Patricia Johns
- A Lancaster Amish Christmas by Anne Blackburne; Amy Clipston; Amy Lillard; Mindy Steele
- The Mother’s Day Bargain by Martha Fouts
- The Novel Adventures of Natalie Daughtry by Susan L. Tuttle
- Small Town Harmony by Milla Holt
- The Shop Down the Laneby Leslie Gould
- Their Texas Christmas Redemption by Mindy Obenhaus
- Their Surprise Reunion by Shelley Shepard Gray
Friends to More: A solid friendship quietly deepens into something more meaningful.
- An Amish Barn Raising: Three Stories by Amy Clipston, Kelly Irvin, Kathleen Fuller
- An Amish Bookshop Courtship by Patricia Johns
- The Amish Baby Scandal by Virginia Wise
- Amish Love Letters by Shelley Shepard Gray, Charlotte Hubbard, Rosalind Lauer
- Christmas at Sugar Plum Manor by Roseanna M. White
- Following the Clues by Dana Mentink
- Her Pretend Holiday Beau by Susanne Dietze
- The Marriage Pact by Kathleen Fuller
- The Mother’s Day Bargain by Martha Fouts
- The Peacemaker by Wanda E. Brunstetter
- Rediscovering Christmas by Mindy Obenhaus
- Season of Hope by Sara Jane Jacobs (Author), Lisa Lynn Sandlin (Narrator)
- Serenity’s Secret by Lisa Jones Baker
- Shadowed Witness by Angela Carlisle
- So Into You by Kathleen Fuller
- Still Waters by Patricia Johns
- With This Ring by Amy Clipston
Enemies to More: Tension and resistance slowly give way to understanding and love.
- Falling for the Amish Rival by Virginia Wise
- Fa-La-La-La Faking It by Teri Wilson
- Her Forbidden Christmas Match by Emma Miller
- His Perfect Bride by Jody Hedlund
- The Hunted Heir by Jayna Breigh
- Kissing the Texas Ranger by Cari Lynn Webb
- My Grumpy Boss Valentine by Em Tate
- An Overdue Match by Sarah Monzon
- Sense and Suitability by Pepper Basham
- Shooting Sunshine by Wendy Rich Stetson
- The Shop Down the Laneby Leslie Gould
- The Way of Water by Toni Cabell (Author), Lisa Lynn Sandlin (Narrator)
- When Stars Light the Sky by Elizabeth Camden
- Winning Over the Baker by Danielle Thorne
- Written In Secret by Crystal Caudill
- Yours Blindly by Rose Fresquez
Close Proximity: Time together is unavoidable, and feelings have no place to hide.
- A Guardian Till Christmas by Danielle Thorne
- The Fire Chief’s Surprise by Chris Maday Schmidt
- Her Amish Refuge by Pamela Desmond Wright
- His Amish Christmas Surprise by Virginia Wise
- Rediscovering Christmas by Mindy Obenhaus
- Rescued at Christmas by Janice Carter
- Shooting Sunshine by Wendy Rich Stetson
- Still Waters by Patricia Johns
- A Thieving at Carlton House by Erica Vetsch
- Yours Blindly by Rose Fresquez
Forced Proximity: Circumstances push characters together, accelerating emotional connection.
- Amish Sleigh Bells by Patricia Johns
- Christmas at Spruce Hill Farm by Kathryn Springer
- Fa-La-La-La Faking It by Teri Wilson
- A Family on His Doorstep by Alena Auguste
- A Guardian Till Christmas by Danielle Thorne
- Heart of Beauty by Danielle Grandinetti
- Her Amish Refuge by Pamela Desmond Wright
- Kissing the Texas Ranger by Cari Lynn Webb
- The Marriage Pact by Kathleen Fuller
- My Grumpy Boss Valentine by Em Tate
- The Novel Adventures of Natalie Daughtry by Susan L. Tuttle
- A Stolen Kiss by Mindy Steele
Hidden Connection: Love forms before identities or assumptions get in the way.
- Amish Love Letters by Shelley Shepard Gray, Charlotte Hubbard, Rosalind Lauer
- Falling for the Amish Rival by Virginia Wise
- The Other Sister by Jessica R. Patch
- The Shop Down the Lane by Leslie Gould
- So Into You by Kathleen Fuller
Marriage of Convenience: A practical arrangement unexpectedly grows into real affection.
- Amish Love Letters by Shelley Shepard Gray, Charlotte Hubbard, Rosalind Lauer
- A Convenient Christmas Wife by Rebecca Kertz
- Falling for the Amish Rival by Virginia Wise
- The Farmer’s Marriage Bargain by Heidi Main
- The Fire Chief’s Surprise by Chris Maday Schmidt
- His Perfect Bride by Jody Hedlund
- A Home for His Amish Children by Virginia Wise
- A Stolen Kiss by Mindy Steele
- When Stars Light the Sky by Elizabeth Camden
Love as Ministry: Serving others becomes the backdrop for romance and faith in action.
- Fa-La-La-La Faking It by Teri Wilson
- The Fire Chief’s Surprise by Chris Maday Schmidt
- Her Amish Refuge by Pamela Desmond Wright
- Rescued at Christmas by Janice Carter
- A Scheming in Parliament by Erica Vetsch
- A Thieving at Carlton House by Erica Vetsch
- With All Her Heart by Kelly Irvin
Character and Occupation Tropes
Competent Heroines: Strong, capable women who lead with intelligence, compassion, and purpose.
- Discovering Dahlia by Jennifer Moore
- The Lightness of Water by Toni Cabell (Author), Lisa Lynn Sandlin (Narrator)
- Lizzie’s Little Mouse by Anne Blackburne
- A Scheming in Parliament by Erica Vetsch
- The Way of Water by Toni Cabell (Author), Lisa Lynn Sandlin (Narrator)
- When Stars Light the Sky by Elizabeth Camden
- Written In Secret by Crystal Caudill
Men in Uniform: Heroes shaped by duty, service, and the weight of responsibility.
- Amish Country Killer by Mary Alford
- An Amish Widow’s Hope by Pamela Desmond Wright
- Capture the Moment by Suzanne Woods Fisher
- The Fire Chief’s Surprise by Chris Maday Schmidt
- Kissing the Texas Ranger by Cari Lynn Webb
- Kissing the Texas Ranger by Cari Lynn Webb
- Rescued at Christmas by Janice Carter
- Season of Hope by Sara Jane Jacobs (Author), Lisa Lynn Sandlin (Narrator)
- Tracking the Missing by Sami A. Abrams
- Written In Secret by Crystal Caudill
Farmers and Land Stewards: Lives rooted in the land, marked by patience, legacy, and faithfulness.
- The Farmer’s Marriage Bargain by Heidi Main
- Kissing the Texas Ranger by Cari Lynn Webb
Caregivers and Healers: Love grows through tending to bodies, hearts, and everyday needs.
- Murder in the Appalachians by Susan Furlong
- Kidnapped for Ransom by Jacqueline Adam
- Still Waters by Patricia Johns
- Their Inseparable Bond by Jill Weatherholt
Single Parent or Guardian: Romance unfolds while caring for children or loved ones comes first.
- An Amish Baby in Her Arms by Patricia Johns
- The Amish Baby Scandal by Virginia Wise
- An Amish Widow’s Hope by Pamela Desmond Wright
- Abducted in the Woods by Kerry Johnson
- A Convenient Christmas Wife by Rebecca Kertz
- A Family on His Doorstep by Alena Auguste
- The Farmer’s Marriage Bargain by Heidi Main
- The Fire Chief’s Surprise by Chris Maday Schmidt
- A Guardian Till Christmas by Danielle Thorne
- Her Amish Country Husband by Patricia Johns
- His Amish Christmas Surprise by Virginia Wise
- Her Forbidden Christmas Match by Emma Miller
- A Home for His Amish Children by Virginia Wise
- Hunted for the Holidays by Deena Alexander
- Hunting the Amish Witness by Dana R. Lynn
- Kate Landry Has a Plan by Rebekah Millet
- A Lancaster Amish Christmas by Anne Blackburne; Amy Clipston; Amy Lillard; Mindy Steele
- Madly Yours by Elle M. Adams
- Rediscovering Christmas by Mindy Obenhaus
- Taken at Christmas by Jodie Bailey
- Their Inseparable Bond by Jill Weatherholt
- Rediscovering Christmas by Mindy Obenhaus
- An Unexpected Companion by Mindy Obenhaus
- Winning Over the Baker by Danielle Thorne
Guarded or Tortured Hero: A man carrying deep wounds learns how to open his heart again.
- A is For Amish by Shelley Shepard Gray
- The Fire Chief’s Surprise by Chris Maday Schmidt
- Her Amish Refuge by Pamela Desmond Wright
- His Perfect Bride by Jody Hedlund
- Hunting for a Husband by Mindy Steele
- Season of Hope by Sara Jane Jacobs (Author), Lisa Lynn Sandlin (Narrator)
- Serenity’s Secret by Lisa Jones Baker
- So Into You by Kathleen Fuller
- An Unexpected Companion by Mindy Obenhaus
Setting and Community Tropes
Small Town Romance: Community matters, everyone knows everyone, and relationships run deep.
- Their Texas Christmas Redemption by Mindy Obenhaus
- Madly Yours by Elle M. Adams
- The Mother’s Day Bargain by Martha Fouts
- An Overdue Match by Sarah Monzon
- Winning Over the Baker by Danielle Thorne
Return Home: Coming back sparks healing, reflection, and unexpected love
- An Amish Bookshop Courtship by Patricia Johns
- B Is for Bonnet by Shelley Shepard Gray
- Christmas at Sugar Plum Manor by Roseanna M. White
- A Guardian Till Christmas by Danielle Thorne
- Her Amish Country Husband by Patricia Johns
- Kate Landry Has a Plan by Rebekah Millet
- Sense and Suitability by Pepper Basham
- Their Surprise Reunion by Shelley Shepard Gray
- A Year of Flowers by Suzanne Woods Fisher
Faith Centered Communities: Church and shared belief shape choices, relationships, and growth.
- Grandma Ruth Doesn’t Go to Funerals by Sharon Mondragon
- Her Pretend Holiday Beau by Susanne Dietze
- With This Ring by Amy Clipston
Rural and Agricultural Settings: Quiet landscapes influence the pace, values, and heart of the story.
- Shooting Sunshine by Wendy Rich Stetson
Found Family: Support and love come from unexpected places beyond blood ties.
- Grandma Ruth Doesn’t Go to Funerals by Sharon Mondragon
- Lizzie’s Little Mouse by Anne Blackburne
- Rescued at Christmas by Janice Carter
- Their Inseparable Bond by Jill Weatherholt
- A Year of Flowers by Suzanne Woods Fisher
Suspense and Danger Tropes
Kidnapping or Abduction: A disappearance raises the stakes and drives urgency and fear.
- Abducted in the Woods by Kerry Johnson
- Following the Clues by Dana Mentink
- Kidnapped for Ransom by Jacqueline Adam
- The Lightness of Water by Toni Cabell (Author), Lisa Lynn Sandlin (Narrator)
- Tracking the Missing by Sami A. Abrams
The Protector: One person takes responsibility for another’s safety, at all costs.
- Abducted in the Woods by Kerry Johnson
- Amish Country Killer by Mary Alford
- Discovering Dahlia by Jennifer Moore
- Following the Clues by Dana Mentink
- Framed in Amish Country by Mary Alford
- Girl Lost by Kate Angelo
- Hunted for the Holidays by Deena Alexander
- Hunting the Amish Witness by Dana R. Lynn
- Kidnapped for Ransom by Jacqueline Adam
- Misgivings by Anne Gibson
- Murder in the Appalachians by Susan Furlong
- The Protector by Wanda E. Brunstetter
- Serenity’s Secret by Lisa Jones Baker
- Shadowed Witness by Angela Carlisle
- Taken at Christmas by Jodie Bailey
Woman in Danger: A heroine becomes a target, forcing courage and reliance on faith.
- Capture the Moment by Suzanne Woods Fisher
- Framed in Amish Country by Mary Alford
- Heart of Beauty by Danielle Grandinetti
- Hunted for the Holidays by Deena Alexander
- Hunting the Amish Witness by Dana R. Lynn
- Hunting for a Husband by Mindy Steele
- Kidnapped for Ransom by Jacqueline Adam
- The Lightness of Water by Toni Cabell (Author), Lisa Lynn Sandlin (Narrator)
- Murder in the Appalachians by Susan Furlong
- The Other Sister by Jessica R. Patch
- Shadowed Witness by Angela Carlisle
- The Way of Water by Toni Cabell (Author), Lisa Lynn Sandlin (Narrator)
Trust No One: Hidden threats demand discernment, prayer, and careful trust.
- Amish Country Killer by Mary Alford
- Canyon of Deceit by DiAnn Mills
- Capture the Moment by Suzanne Woods Fisher
- Framed in Amish Country by Mary Alford
- Girl Lost by Kate Angelo
- Grandma Ruth Doesn’t Go to Funerals by Sharon Mondragon
- The Hunted Heir by Jayna Breigh
- Murder in the Appalachians by Susan Furlong
- The Other Sister by Jessica R. Patch
- The Peacemaker by Wanda E. Brunstetter
- The Protector by Wanda E. Brunstetter
- The Rise and Fall of Miss Fannie’s Biscuits by Wanda E. Brunstetter & Martha Bolton
- A Scheming in Parliament by Erica Vetsch

